Bathtub vs. Walk-in Shower: What's Right for Your Bathroom Remodel?

Bathtub vs. Walk-in Shower: What’s Right for Your Bathroom Remodel?

Whether you’re a homeowner looking to update your bathroom or are in the market for a new home, one of the most important decisions you will face is choosing between installing a bathtub or walk-in shower. This is a choice that should not be taken lightly, as it will impact the functionality and aesthetics of the space for years to come. If you find yourself wrestling with this decision, you’re not alone. Many St. Louis bathroom remodeling contractors report that clients frequently have a hard time determining which option is best suited to their needs and lifestyle. 

There are several key differences homeowners should understand when deciding between a bathtub or walk-in shower. 

Understanding the Differences: Bathtub vs Walk-in Shower

The battle between bathtubs and walk-in showers has forever been a point of contention within the confines of bathroom remodeling projects. Both contenders bring their unique elements to the table — some swear by the relaxation only a bathtub can provide after a long day while others appreciate the practicality and sleek modernity of a walk-in shower. 

Before making your decision, it’s ideal to delve into the various considerations each option presents.

The Iconic Bathtub: A Symbol of Luxury & Leisure 

No one can deny that stepping into a bathtub filled with warm bubbles at the end-of-the-day is extraordinarily soothing. It’s more than just about cleanliness; it’s an escape, providing unparalleled warmth and pure relaxation.

Many homeowners cherish having both options available – dipping into luxury when time permits or dashing through a quick shower during workdays. Additionally, homes with young ones may find tubs indispensable for bath-time routines. Furthermore, potential home buyers often consider bathtubs as must-haves which could boost resale value.

However, bathtubs aren’t exempt from downsides:

– Accessibility Issues: They’re not ideal for seniors or individuals with mobility issues since they demand climbing over high sides.  

– Space Intensive: Compared to walk-in showers, they take up more real estate in your bathroom.    

– Water Usage: Tubs typically use twice as much water as showers would for one cleaning session.

The Contemporary Walk-In Shower: Convenience Meets Modernity

With walk-in showers, you can sashay into a seamless blend of efficiency and sophistication. These fixtures are particularly well-suited to quick rinses but without compromising on comfort or aesthetic quality. With their minimalist design, they effortlessly impart a clean, modern look to your bathroom.

Before plunging headfirst into installing a walk-in shower, bear in mind the following:

– Difficult Conversion: If your bathroom only hosts a bathtub currently, converting it into a walk-in shower may involve considerable work and expense.  

– Saleability Factor: Some buyers prefer bathrooms with both shower and tub options.  

– Water Spillage: Without proper installation and enclosures, water might spill onto other bathroom areas.

Cost Considerations: Making Sense of the Dollars

An essential factor that sways the bathtub vs walk-in shower debate is undoubtedly the cost. According to HomeAdvisor, the average cost for installing a tub ranges between $1,000-$5,000 while putting up a walk-in shower falls within $2,500-$5,000. Costs can vary significantly depending on factors such as:

– The model selected

– Plumbing adjustments needed

– Labor costs 

– Customization options 

Bearing this information in mind will aid in aligning your renovation objectives with financial realities.

Longevity & Maintenance Factors 

Move beyond initial installation; consider ongoing maintenance needs and product longevity when selecting between a bathtub or shower. While bathtubs might require more frequent deep cleaning due to surfaces prone to soap scum buildup or mildew formation, keeping grout lines in showers free from mold can be equally tasking.

In terms of durability though it largely depends on the material used – premium acrylic baths or showers are known for superior longevity should all care instructions be followed meticulously. 

Personalization Options: Design Your Dream Domain

A notable aspect of remodeling is unleashing your creativity — personalizing the space to resonate with your style. Bathtubs and walk-in showers provide ample opportunities for customization. For bathtubs, you can consider freestanding soaking tubs or opt for luxurious jetted models. 

On the other hand, walk-in showers allow you to experiment with diverse tile designs, install frameless glass doors, integrate bench seats or extravagant shower heads.

Let Bath Planet of St. Louis & More. Rejuvenate Your Bathroom

At Bath Planet of St. Louis & More, we understand the importance of striking the right balance between functionality and design in bathroom remodeling ventures. Whether you’re leaning towards a serene soaker tub or an edgy walk-in shower, our experts are ready to transform your vision into reality, promising high-quality products and impeccable installations.

Reach out to us today or visit because nothing beats coming home to a bathroom that feels just right!

Name, Address & Phone:

Bath Planet of St. Louis & More,

2424 Hwy 94 South Outer Rd, St Charles, MO – 63303 – US

(636) 947-0177


Social Account URLS:,,

1 YEAR 0% APR*

Offer Expires 7/31/2022



    *Subject to credit approval. Fixed APR of 0.00% for 12 months. New orders only. Offer not valid on previous sales or estimates and cannot be combined with other offers. Offer expires 7/31/22.


    No time to wait? No problem – Contact us today and we’ll get started on your bathroom remodel right away.